# Heat pump replacement in Boston, MA

> Replace an aging ducted heat pump with one sized again from your house, with the line set, ducts and panel checked first. Typical range $12,000 to $24,000.

URL: https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/heat-pump-replacement/

Service

A new ducted heat pump in place of one at the end of its life, sized again from the house.

(857) 837-1475

Last Updated: November 12, 2026

Sized

From a room-by-room load calculation at your town's design temperature

Measured

Duct static pressure and airflow before and after

Tested

Nitrogen pressure test and deep vacuum before the charge

In writing

Equipment, duct work, electrical and permits listed line by line

## A typical West Roxbury heat pump replacement

The 15-year-old outdoor unit on its settled pad

New variable-speed outdoor unit on an 18-inch stand

### The house and the problem

A 1950s split-level with a 15-year-old single-stage heat pump. The compressor is tripping on overload just as the heating season starts, and last January the 10 kW strips did most of the work on cold nights. The concrete pad under it has settled and tilted toward the foundation.

### Like-for-like or variable speed

The load comes to 33,800 BTU an hour on a 7°F night. The old unit made about 19,000 at 5°F; a 3-ton cold-climate variable-speed unit is rated near 31,000. A single-stage swap prices about $3,700 lower but keeps the strips running, so the plan goes variable speed.

### Keeping the ceiling closed

The 30-foot line set runs inside a finished lower-level ceiling. Its diameters match the new unit's specification, so we flush it and hold it under nitrogen instead of replacing it. Both units change, since the new R-454B equipment needs a matched air handler with a leak sensor.

### Startup and paperwork

Brazed under nitrogen, pulled below 500 microns, charged by weight for 30 feet. The strips drop from 10 to 5 kW and lock out above 10°F. The new unit sits on an 18-inch stand on a fresh pad, and the swap qualifies for Mass Save's basic rebate, about $750.

*Project facts*

| Service | Heat pump replacement |
| --- | --- |
| Where | West Roxbury, Bellevue Hill side |
| House | 1950s split-level, about 1,900 sq ft |
| Before | 15-year-old 3-ton single-stage heat pump, 10 kW strips |
| After | 3-ton variable-speed cold-climate system, 5 kW strips |
| Price | $16,800 before rebates |
| Time on site | Two working days |

The heat pump is 15 years old, the compressor is struggling, and last January’s electric bill showed the backup strips doing the heating. [Clement Boston Heat Pumps](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/) handles heat pump replacement in Boston and the towns within 20 miles, swapping a worn-out ducted system for one sized again from the house.

Our typical range to replace an existing ducted heat pump is $12,000 to $24,000; the home visit and written estimate set your price. Before we price a replacement, we check whether a repair still makes sense.

## Repair it or replace it?

That depends on what failed, how old the system is and how it handled last winter. A failed capacitor or fan motor on a ten-year-old system is a repair. A failed compressor on a 15-year-old one rarely is.

### Signs a repair still makes sense

- One electrical part has failed: a capacitor, contactor, fan motor or control board.
- The indoor coil and air handler are sound, with no history of refrigerant top-ups.
- The house stayed warm last winter without the strips running for days at a time.

### Signs it’s time to replace

- The compressor or outdoor coil has failed on a system well into its second decade.
- The coil leaks and the refrigerant has been topped up more than once.
- The old unit loses most of its output below freezing, so the strips carried every cold night.

Symptoms alone don’t prove a cause. Ice on the outdoor coil can be a normal defrost cycle or a charge problem, and a high bill can come from the strips, the thermostat or a leaky duct. We test before we price either path; our [heat pump repair](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/heat-pump-repair/) page covers the fixes that keep a system going.

## What the first visit covers for a replacement

A replacement visit looks at the house, not the old unit’s nameplate. We redo the load, read the ducts, inspect the line set, check the panel and look hard at where the outdoor unit sits now.

- **Load.** A room-by-room ACCA Manual J at your town’s design temperature. New windows or attic insulation since the first install can shrink the right size; our [sizing guide](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-sizing/) shows the math.
- **Ducts.** Static pressure and airflow on the existing system, so the new blower isn’t fighting a choked return. Fixes go on the estimate as [ductwork](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/heat-pump-ductwork/) lines.
- **Line set.** Diameter, length, route and condition, and whether it suits the new refrigerant.
- **Panel and circuit.** Breaker and wire size for the new outdoor unit and its backup strips.
- **The outdoor spot.** Whether the old pad has sunk, sits under a roof drip line or crowds the neighbor’s lot line.

The estimate names the new equipment with its heating capacity at 5°F, the line set plan, any duct or electrical change, the permits, the rebate and our price.

## Why the old size isn’t automatic

The old tonnage was picked for a different set of equipment, often by rule of thumb. A 15-year-old single-stage unit loses much of its heating output as the air gets colder, so its nameplate says little about what your house needs now.

### What changed in the equipment

Cold-climate [variable-speed](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/guide/variable-speed-heat-pump/) heat pumps hold far more of their output near 5°F than older single-speed units. A new 3-ton system can deliver close to its rated heat on a night when the old one made about half. That changes how much work is left for the strips.

### Like-for-like or variable speed

A like-for-like single-stage swap costs less up front, and it repeats the old pattern: full blast, off, and strips on cold nights. Variable speed runs longer at low output, holds the temperature steady and dries summer air better. When a house could go either way, we price both and show the difference on paper.

## The line set: reuse or replace

The copper lines between the outdoor unit and the air handler can often stay. Whether yours can depends on their size, condition and route, and on what the new equipment’s instructions allow.

Reuse works when the diameters match the new unit’s specification, the run is within its length and lift limits, and the lines pass a flush and a standing nitrogen test. It spares a finished ceiling. Replacement is the call when lines are undersized, kinked, badly insulated or full of old oil.

### The refrigerant change

New heat pumps run on lower-impact refrigerants such as R-454B or R-32 in place of R-410A. These are classed as mildly flammable, so most new air handlers carry a refrigerant leak sensor, and the indoor and outdoor units change as a matched pair. Our [R-454B guide](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-refrigerant-r454b/) explains what that means for a swap.

## How the swap goes, start to finish

A replacement follows the same order as a new install, with the old refrigerant recovered first. Most basement-to-yard swaps take one to two working days on site once the permit is issued.

1. Recover the old refrigerant and remove both units.
2. Set the outdoor unit level on a stand above drifting snow, out from under the roof edge ([snow stands](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-snow-stand/)).
3. Set the air handler and connect the plenum, return, condensate trap and float switch.
4. Braze the lines under flowing nitrogen, then pressure-test them.
5. Pull a vacuum below 500 microns and confirm it holds.
6. Weigh in the charge for the actual line length.
7. Measure airflow and static, set the [thermostat](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-thermostat/) and record the backup heat lockout.

You get the readings in writing, so the next service visit starts from known numbers instead of guesses.

## Rebates when you replace a heat pump

A heat-pump-for-heat-pump swap earns Mass Save’s basic rebate, $250 per ton up to $2,500. The larger whole-home and partial-home rebates pay for displacing oil, propane, gas or electric resistance heat, not for upgrading a heat pump.

| Your situation | What applies |
| --- | --- |
| Eversource or National Grid electric | Basic rebate for qualifying equipment installed by a participating contractor |
| A light plant town such as [Braintree](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/service-areas/braintree/) or [Peabody](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/service-areas/peabody/) | The town utility’s own program, which sets its own terms for replacements |
| Any Eversource, National Grid or Unitil heat pump home | The [winter heat pump rate](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-electric-rate-massachusetts/) on household electricity |

Basic rebates go through electric sponsors only, and the equipment has to be on Mass Save’s cold-climate qualified list. We confirm current figures for your address when we write the estimate.

## What moves the price of a replacement

Most of the spread in our $12,000 to $24,000 range comes from the equipment tier and what has to change around it.

- Capacity and tier: single-stage, two-stage or variable speed.
- Line set reused or replaced, and how hard a new route is.
- Air handler location: an open basement against a tight closet or an [attic install](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/attic-air-handler-heat-pump/).
- Duct fixes found on the static test.
- Electrical work, from a new disconnect to a [service upgrade](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/electrical-panel-upgrade-for-heat-pump/).

Our [cost guide](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-installation-cost-massachusetts/) puts replacement beside the other jobs we price. If only the indoor unit is failing, an [air handler replacement](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/heat-pump-air-handler-replacement/) may be the smaller job.

## What's included

- A repair-or-replace check on the failing system before anything is priced
- A new load calculation, duct static reading and panel check
- Recovery of the old refrigerant and removal of both old units
- A matched outdoor unit and air handler on the new refrigerant
- Line set flushed and pressure-tested for reuse, or replaced where it falls short
- A stand above drifting snow, a new disconnect and a condensate float switch
- Nitrogen pressure test, vacuum below 500 microns and charge by weight
- Measured airflow, controls set and the backup heat lockout written down

## Three ways to deal with a failing heat pump

|  | Repair the old system | Like-for-like replacement | Variable-speed cold-climate replacement |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Up-front cost | Lowest, if the failed part is minor | Middle of our range | Upper part of our range |
| Heat on a 5°F night | Whatever the old unit still makes | Similar to the old unit when new | Close to rated output on most cold-climate models |
| Backup strips | Carry the cold nights as before | Carry the cold nights as before | Kick in only below the balance point |
| Mass Save | None | Basic rebate if the unit is on the qualified list | Basic rebate, $250 per ton up to $2,500 |
| Refrigerant | Stays on the old one | New refrigerant, matched pair | New refrigerant, matched pair |

## Related resources

- [Learn**How long does a heat pump last?** No one can promise a heat pump a number of years. What you can control is the install, the sizing and the upkeep that decide most of it.](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-lifespan/)
- [Learn**What does the switch to R-454B refrigerant mean for my heat pump?** New ducted heat pumps use lower-impact refrigerants. Here's why, what it changes when you repair or replace a system, and what it doesn't.](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-refrigerant-r454b/)
- [Learn**What size heat pump do I need?** Why square footage and the old unit's tonnage both mislead, what a room-by-room load calculation measures, and how the result turns into equipment.](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-sizing/)
- [Decision Guide**What questions should I ask a heat pump installer before I sign?** Two quotes for the same house can describe very different jobs. These questions show you which one you're actually buying.](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-quote-checklist/)
- [Decision Guide**What's involved in replacing a heat pump in a condo?** In a condo, the outdoor unit usually sits on common property, so the association, the master deed and sometimes a historic commission come before equipment.](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/guide/condo-heat-pump-replacement/)

## How a job runs

### First call

You tell us what heats and cools the house now, which rooms aren't working, and roughly where the house is.

### Home visit

We measure the house for a load calculation, test the ducts, check the panel and look for an outdoor spot.

### Written estimate

Equipment, duct changes, electrical, permits and the rebate path, line by line, with our price.

### Install

Permits first, then the work: usually two to five working days on site.

### Commissioning

Pressure test, vacuum, charge by weight, airflow and controls set before we call it done.

## Heat pump replacement: questions

### Can I replace just the outdoor unit of my heat pump?

Rarely. New outdoor units run on R-454B or R-32, and the indoor coil has to be listed with the outdoor unit and built for the same refrigerant. An indoor unit from an older R-410A system won't qualify, so a replacement normally includes both halves. If only the indoor side has failed, that's a different job.

### Will my old line set work with the new refrigerant?

Often, if the copper is the size the new unit's instructions call for, the run is within its length limit, and the lines pass a flush and a nitrogen pressure test. Undersized, kinked or poorly insulated lines get replaced. We check before the estimate, because reuse can save opening a finished ceiling.

### How long does a heat pump replacement take?

Most basement-to-yard swaps take one to two working days on site once the permit is in hand. A new line set through finished space, an attic air handler, duct fixes or a service upgrade add time. The heat is off for part of a day, so in winter we plan the cut-over around the weather.

### Does replacing a heat pump qualify for Mass Save rebates?

Replacing a heat pump with a heat pump earns the basic rebate, $250 per ton up to $2,500, for qualifying equipment installed by a participating contractor. The whole-home and partial-home rebates are for displacing oil, propane, gas or electric resistance heat, so they don't apply to a straight swap.

### Do you take the old heat pump away?

Yes. The refrigerant is recovered into a recovery cylinder before anything is disconnected, then both old units, the old disconnect if it's replaced and the packaging leave with the job. The estimate lists removal as its own line so you can see it.

## Related services

- [Service**Air handler replacement** A new indoor unit matched to the outdoor heat pump you already have.](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/heat-pump-air-handler-replacement/)
- [Service**Heat pump repair** Ducted heat pumps that won't heat, ice up, short cycle or leak, diagnosed by measurement.](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/heat-pump-repair/)
- [Service**Heat pump ductwork** Duct testing, sealing, new returns and resized runs so a heat pump gets the air it needs.](https://clementbostonheatpumps.com/heat-pump-ductwork/)

## Get an estimate for heat pump replacement

Tell us what heats it now and which rooms aren't working. We'll measure, lay out the system and the ducts, and put the plan and the price in writing.

(857) 837-1475
